top of page
  • Carolyn Lighty

Is a Fractional CMO the Unicorn Your Company Didn't Know It Needed?

Building Your 2024 Marketing Evolution Roadmap: How To Hire The Ideal Fractional CMO

In the rapidly evolving landscape of business strategies, the role of a Fractional Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) has emerged as a transformative solution for companies seeking dynamic marketing leadership without committing to a full-time executive. For CXOs navigating this territory, finding and engaging the right Fractional CMO can significantly impact their company's growth trajectory.

The journey toward hiring a Fractional CMO begins with a deep understanding of your company's specific needs, available internal resources, and aspirations. This involves a comprehensive assessment of your current marketing landscape, identifying areas of improvement, and outlining precise goals you aim to achieve through this strategic partnership.

Tips to help you determine the feasibility of working with a Fractional CMO:

  • Assess your current marketing landscape:

    • Conduct an in-depth analysis of your current marketing strategies, their effectiveness, and areas requiring improvement.

    • Identify gaps in your marketing approach, whether it's in digital presence, lead generation, customer engagement, funnel optimization or brand positioning.

    • Determine if existing skill sets are capable of developing the strategy and executing the tactical plan required to drive your revenue growth and market development goals.

  • Identify areas requiring improvement:

    • Pinpoint specific challenges hindering your marketing efforts, such as inconsistent messaging, ineffective targeting, budget or limited conversion rates.

    • Prioritize these areas based on their impact on your business goals and growth potential.

  • Outline specific goals for the partnership:

    • Define precise objectives you aim to achieve by engaging a Fractional CMO, such as increasing lead generation by X%, boosting brand visibility, or entering new markets.

    • Ensure these goals align with your broader business strategies and are measurable to track progress effectively.

    • Establish a weekly cadence for checkpoint meetings and issue resolution.

Hunting Unicorns: Selecting Your Dream CMO

Before initiating the search process, it's imperative to define clear expectations and objectives for the Fractional CMO role. Articulate the scope of responsibilities, preferred skill sets, and the level of involvement expected in your company's strategic decision-making processes and the internal resource requirements that will be needed to aid plan execution. This clarity serves as a foundational guide in your search for the ideal candidate.

Tips to get you started:

  • Clearly define the scope of responsibilities:

    • Draft a detailed job description outlining the responsibilities and expected deliverables for the Fractional CMO role.

    • Include specifics on involvement in strategic planning, team collaboration, and reporting structures.

  • Specify preferred skill sets for the role:

    • Identify key competencies required, such as strategic thinking, data analytics proficiency, experience in diverse marketing channels, and leadership capabilities.

    • Prioritize skills that complement your existing team's expertise to ensure a well-rounded approach.

  • Determine the level of involvement in strategic decision-making:

    • Decide the level of autonomy and authority the Fractional CMO will have in shaping marketing strategies.

    • Define the role within your company's hierarchy and the extent of interaction with other executive team members.

    • Ascertain the Internal resource allocation requirement for plan execution

    • Identify internal resources that will be assigned tactical responsibilities and estimate the percentage of their day that will be allocated to supporting the Fractional CMO.

What Extraordinary Qualities & Experience Should Your Fractional CMO Have?

When vetting potential Fractional CMOs, if we use the sought after qualities of a high performing “Thoroughbred”, these parallels illustrate how the qualities of a Thoroughbred can be metaphorically matched to those desirable in a Fractional CMO. The goal is to select a Fractional CMO that can bring a diverse skill set, encompassing not only marketing expertise but also a profound understanding of business objectives and the agility to navigate evolving market landscapes.

Tips to help you recognize your unicorn:

  • Speed and Agility: A Fractional CMO needs to be quick on their feet, adapting rapidly to changing market trends and client needs.

  • Muscular Build: In a metaphorical sense, this could represent a robust skill set and knowledge base, indicating a Fractional CMO's expertise and capabilities in various marketing domains.

  • High Stamina: Fractional CMOs often work on demanding schedules, requiring endurance to handle multiple projects and deadlines without compromising quality.

  • Elegant Appearance: This can translate to a professional demeanor and polished presentation skills, crucial for client interactions and delivering impactful marketing strategies.

  • Temperament: Similar to a Thoroughbred's spirited nature, a Fractional CMO may need a degree of enthusiasm, confidence, and assertiveness to navigate demands and challenges related to the internal staff’s buy-in. 

  • Versatility: A Fractional CMO is adaptable, capable of switching strategies and approaches to suit different industries and client requirements.

  • Adaptability: Adapting to new technologies, tools, and platforms in the ever-evolving marketing landscape is vital for a consultant's success.

  • Heritage and Bloodlines: In the marketing world, this could symbolize a Fractional CMO's experience, expertise, and reputation, often built on a solid track record of successful strategic plan implementations.

  • Intelligence: An aptitude for strategic thinking, data analysis, and quick decision-making aligns with the intelligence of a Thoroughbred, enabling consultants to devise effective marketing plans based on best practices, agility and results.

  • Characteristics for Racing: For a Fractional CMO, this would be the ability to work swiftly, strategically and effectively in competitive marketplaces, aiming for dominance, top performance and sustainable results.

Cultural Alignment and Collaborative Fit

Beyond qualifications, focus on cultural alignment and collaborative compatibility. Assess how well a prospective Fractional CMO aligns with your company's values, work culture, and the ability to seamlessly integrate with your existing teams. Effective collaboration is as crucial as individual expertise in ensuring the success of this partnership.

Tips to help you determine synergy:

  • Assess alignment with company values and culture:

    • Share your company's core values and culture during the interview process.

    • Gauge candidates' alignment by discussing past experiences and how they align with your company's ethos.

  • Gauge compatibility with your existing teams:

    • Arrange meetings or discussions with potential Fractional CMO candidates and key team members to gauge chemistry and compatibility.

    • Observe how well they interact with your team and their ability to integrate seamlessly.

  • Evaluate communication and collaboration style:

    • Ask candidates about their preferred communication methods and frequency of updates.

    • Inquire about their experiences collaborating with diverse teams and managing remote work if applicable.

Engaging in a Thorough Selection Process

Implement a comprehensive selection process that involves rigorous interviews, case studies, and reference checks. Encourage candidates to present their strategic vision for your business and evaluate their ability to articulate a cohesive and actionable marketing plan tailored to your company's unique needs.

Tips to narrow the field of candidates:

  • Conduct rigorous interviews:

    • Prepare a structured interview process with tailored questions that assess the candidate's expertise and problem-solving skills.

    • Consider presenting a hypothetical scenario or case study relevant to your industry to evaluate their approach.

    • Encourage candidates to provide you with samples of plans, campaigns, etc.

  • Request candidates to present strategic visions:

    • Ask candidates to outline their strategic vision for your business based on their initial research and the information provided during the interview process.

    • Evaluate their understanding of your company's needs, the marketplace you serve and their ability to develop actionable plans.

  • Check references:

    • Contact provided references to gain insights into the candidate's previous work, collaboration style, and overall performance.

    • Seek feedback on their strengths, areas for improvement, and their impact on previous organizations.

Embracing Flexibility and Agility

One of the core advantages of engaging a Fractional CMO lies in their adaptability and flexibility. Embrace their agility in responding to market changes swiftly and aligning strategies to meet evolving customer needs. This flexibility adds significant value to your company's resilience in a dynamic marketplace.

Tips to get to the core of their ability to move people, places and things efficiently and at a fast pace:

  • Determine the candidate's agility in responding to market changes:

    • Discuss past experiences where candidates adapted strategies swiftly to address market shifts or changing consumer behaviors.

    • Evaluate their willingness to pivot strategies and embrace innovative approaches.

  • Evaluate capacity to align strategies with dynamic customer needs:

    • Assess their approach to understanding customer behavior and preferences through data analytics and market research.

    • Inquire about their methodologies for crafting customer-centric strategies that evolve with market demands.

Establishing Clear Communication and KPIs

Finally, establish transparent communication channels and delineate key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure the success of your Fractional CMO engagement. Regular checkpoints and a robust feedback mechanism ensure alignment with your business objectives and facilitate course corrections when needed.

Tips to avoid misalignment & miscommunication:

  • Set up transparent communication channels:

    • Define regular communication touchpoints, reporting structures, and preferred tools for collaboration.

    • Establish open lines of communication to foster transparency and encourage feedback.

  • Define key performance indicators (KPIs) for evaluation:

    • Identify specific metrics aligned with your business goals, such as lead generation rates, conversion rates, brand visibility, etc.

    • Ensure these KPIs are measurable and directly attributable to the Fractional CMO's contributions.

  • Implement regular checkpoints and feedback mechanisms:

    • Schedule periodic reviews to evaluate progress against established KPIs and goals.

    • Encourage open discussions and feedback sessions to address any challenges and refine strategies accordingly.

In conclusion, the process of finding and hiring the right Fractional CMO demands a strategic approach, meticulous assessment, and a keen eye for alignment with your company's vision. By prioritizing experience, cultural fit, and a shared vision for growth, CXOs can unlock the full potential of this transformative partnership with a unicorn that can drive their businesses toward unprecedented success.


bottom of page